Embracing the Expertise of Returning Citizens: Valuing Lived Experiences

Embracing the Expertise of Returning Citizens: Valuing Lived Experiences

What do returning citizens offer when we embrace their lived experiences and expertise? Engaging with this untapped reservoir of lived wisdom empowers us to refine criminal justice frameworks, innovate reintegration practices, and bolster societal unity. This article delves into the practical and impactful ways that society stands to gain from embracing the expertise of returning citizens valuing lived experiences, without the gloss but with a keen eye on genuine transformation. Expect to discover how their lived experiences translate into a catalytic force for reform, rehabilitation, and community revitalization.

Key Takeaways

  • Programs led by individuals with firsthand experience of the criminal justice system, such as ELEVATE CJS, promote systemic change and benefit returning citizens through higher rates of successful community reintegration, reduced recidivism, and improved access to resources, despite existing challenges to their integration in policy-making processes.
  • Education, including tailored educational opportunities and correctional education, serves as a foundational tool for reintegration, enhancing employment prospects and reducing recidivism, while community engagement and partnerships provide crucial support and resources for successful societal reentry.
  • Inclusivity in employment, policymaking, and research is essential for integrating returning citizens, with holistic approaches addressing stigma, providing comprehensive support services, and leveraging lived experiences for innovation, thereby fostering a more inclusive, effective, and rehabilitative criminal justice system.

The Role of Lived Experience in Shaping Criminal Justice Reform

The power of lived experience is often underestimated. The insights gleaned from such experiences can have far-reaching implications, particularly in the realm of criminal justice reform. Take, for instance, programs like ELEVATE CJS. Led by those who have been through the criminal justice system themselves, these programs are effectively spearheading systemic change. Their leadership and input are invaluable, and more than that, they make a tangible difference.

Policies informed by the input of a few individuals contribute to:

  • higher rates of successful community reintegration
  • reduced recidivism rates
  • improved access to resources and support
  • increased understanding and empathy within the criminal justice system

These benefits extend beyond the individuals themselves and have a positive impact on society as a whole.

Yet, obstacles exist that prevent the full utilization of these insights. Complex vetting procedures and unsupportive workplace cultures can constrain the influence of returning citizens on the criminal justice system. Addressing these different challenges urgently is crucial, lest we miss out on this valuable resource. In this way, support for returning citizens extends beyond individuals to fortify the criminal justice system, making it more attuned to the realities of those it serves.

The role of lived experience in shaping criminal justice reform is undeniable. It’s not just about acknowledging the value of these experiences; it’s about actively integrating them into our systems and structures. Only then can we hope to achieve a justice system that is reflective of the diverse voices it serves.

Harnessing Personal Narratives for Systemic Change

Unique and unfiltered, the personal narratives of returning citizens present a distinct perspective on the realities of the criminal justice system. These stories illuminate the intricacies of the system, prompting much-needed discussions around reform. Individuals like Bueno, a returning citizen, are making a significant impact in this regard. Through storytelling, Bueno is utilizing his unique perspective and connections with other returning citizens to influence media and spotlight areas in need of reform.

The skills that individuals like Bueno possess are irreplaceable. Skills such as conflict resolution, critical thinking, and effective communication are not just beneficial in roles in media, but they also aid in highlighting reform needs. These individuals are not just narrating their stories; they’re using them as a tool for change.

Harnessing personal narratives for systemic change is about recognizing and valuing the unique insights that returning citizens bring to the table. It’s about understanding that their lived experience within the criminal justice system is a powerful tool in effecting change. By creating platforms for these narratives to be shared, we can build a more inclusive, effective, and humane justice system.

Building Bridges with Community Engagement

Community engagement plays a pivotal role in the successful reintegration of returning citizens. By fostering a supportive environment and offering access to crucial resources, community engagement programs have been shown to:

  • Reduce recidivism rates
  • Empower returning citizens
  • Provide support
  • Prevent re-offending

Initiatives driven by returnees, such as peer support groups, not only empower the participants but also work effectively to prevent re-offending.

It’s not just about developing programs; it’s also about creating partnerships. Establishing collaborations between non-profit organizations and returning citizens creates pathways for mentorship, skill development, and advocacy. Joint ventures between businesses and returning citizen groups contribute to the economic development of communities and help normalize the reintegration process. By building these bridges, we’re not just supporting returning citizens; we’re also strengthening our communities.

Community networks, therefore, play an essential role in this process. They assist with job placement, housing, and access to mental health services, providing a support system that returning citizens can rely on. Events like Life After Prison are a testament to the power of community engagement. By providing a safe space for discussion, education, and healing, these events address the mental health challenges during the reentry process.

In essence, relationship building through community engagement means providing the support, resources, and opportunities that returning citizens need to rebuild their lives and become active, contributing members of society.

From Incarceration to Innovation

A path marked by resilience and transformation characterizes the journey from incarceration to innovation. At the heart of this journey are programs that seek to leverage the lived experiences of returning citizens to drive systemic change. The Prison Education Project in California is a prime example. This initiative provides incarcerated individuals with educational opportunities, focusing on their academic, life skills, and career development to support their reintegration. The project employs a tiered strategy that aids human development, reduces recidivism, and helps formerly incarcerated individuals reengage economically and civically with society.

Similarly, programs like ELEVATE CJS are designed to promote leadership based on lived experiences. They assist those with personal encounters with the criminal justice system to occupy roles that influence transformative change. By focusing on leadership and empowerment, these programs are shifting the narrative from one of incarceration to one of innovation.

From incarceration to innovation - it’s a journey that underscores the power of lived experiences. By harnessing these narratives and integrating them into innovative programs, we’re not just supporting the reintegration process; we’re also driving systemic change in the criminal justice system. It’s about acknowledging that those who have been through the system have a unique perspective that can be utilized to improve it, ensuring it’s more responsive, effective, and ultimately, more just.

Transformative Knowledge: Education as a Tool for Reintegration

Especially relevant to the reintegration of returning citizens, education proves to be a formidable tool. The Reentry Education Tool Kit, supported by the U.S. Department of Education, provides a foundation for education providers to support the reintegration of individuals with criminal histories. The Reentry Education Framework guidelines aim to deliver high-quality education to adults in the criminal justice system, enhancing their reintegration success. It’s not just about providing education; it’s about providing the right kind of education.

Programs like ELEVATE CJS are enriching emerging leaders with lived experience in the criminal justice system by:

  • Providing tailored educational opportunities that cater to their unique needs and circumstances
  • Enabling them to further their career and drive systemic change
  • Equipping returning citizens with the skills and knowledge they need to reintegrate successfully into society

Significant returns result from investments in prison-based correctional education and vocational training. By reducing recidivism and increasing the likelihood of employment upon release, these initiatives are not just benefiting the individuals involved; they’re also benefiting society as a whole. Transformative knowledge, therefore, is not just about education; it’s about empowerment, opportunity, and ultimately, successful reintegration.

Educational Opportunities Tailored for Returning Citizens

Tailored educational initiatives for returning citizens are making a significant difference in their reintegration journey. By equipping them with skills for sustainable, living-wage occupations, these initiatives are not just supporting their reentry, but also their long-term success. Such initiatives have been shown to improve post-release employment outcomes and notably reduce recidivism rates.

Take, for instance, the Prison Education Project. This initiative fosters a ‘Prison-to-School Pipeline’ by providing cognitive tools for incarcerated individuals, facilitating their transition into productive citizenship upon reentry. It’s about recognizing the potential of these individuals and providing them with the tools they need to realize it.

Educational opportunities tailored for returning citizens are therefore crucial. They provide these individuals with a pathway to employment and a chance at a better life. More than that, they contribute to a safer, more inclusive society, one where everyone, regardless of their past, has the opportunity to succeed.

Mentorship and Peer Support Networks

Mentorship and peer support networks play a vital role in the reintegration of returning citizens. These networks provide guidance, resources, and most importantly, support. Programs like the ‘I Choose Support’ mentoring movement and Amicus Reconnect involve community volunteers in supporting the reintegration of returning citizens. These mentors provide guidance on a range of life skills, from employment and housing to goal setting and stress management, establishing a trusting relationship that extends beyond the confines of the criminal justice system.

Organizations like Reimagine Reentry are also focusing on reconnecting returning citizens with their children through educational programs and family reunification initiatives. Parental and fatherhood coaching becomes critical in mentorship as it addresses the significant demographic of returning citizens who are parents, aiming to strengthen family ties and promote healthy community engagement. It’s about recognizing that reintegration is not just about the individual, but also about their families and communities.

Mentorship and peer support networks play an integral role in the reintegration process. They provide a support system that returning citizens can rely on, one that understands their unique needs and challenges. Through these networks, returning citizens are:

  • Receiving support
  • Building connections
  • Developing skills
  • Laying the groundwork for a successful reentry.

Cultivating Hope through Employment Opportunities

Employment opportunities for returning citizens extend beyond simply offering a source of income; they foster hope as well. Certain states have moved to protect these individuals by creating laws that prevent private employers from asking about criminal backgrounds until a job offer has been extended. This is a step in the right direction, but there’s more to be done. Employers who hire returning citizens are eligible for federal and state tax benefits, which can further incentivize the hiring of these individuals.

An inclusive workplace for returning citizens can be cultivated through employee training programs and by conducting interview processes that focus on skills and qualifications without biased consideration of criminal history. This not only creates an environment where returning citizens can thrive but also helps to break down the barriers that often hinder their employment opportunities. The importance of employment in mitigating the negative consequences of being labeled a felon underscores the societal benefit of integrating returning citizens into the workforce.

Cultivating hope through employment opportunities is therefore a critical aspect of reintegration. It’s about providing returning citizens with the chance to rebuild their lives, to contribute to society, and to move beyond their past. By creating these opportunities, we’re not just supporting returning citizens; we’re also strengthening our communities and our economy.

Case Studies of Success

The potential of returning citizens in the workforce is highlighted by successful reentry initiatives and corporate commitments. Model initiatives like the Full Circle Auto Repair & Training Center provide returning citizens with advanced training, paid internships, and guaranteed job placement after graduation. Similarly, the WorkWell Partnership has supported over 200 returning citizens in securing sustainable employment within a year of its operation. These case studies illustrate the potential of returning citizens when given the right opportunities and support.

Prominent figures such as Robert Downey Jr., Les Brown, Martha Stewart, and Snoop Dogg, among others, illustrate the spectrum of success returning citizens can achieve post-incarceration across various industries. Their stories serve as a testament to the potential of returning citizens, underscoring the need for supportive reentry initiatives. In the corporate world, companies like American Airlines, Google, and The Hershey Company have shown their commitment to hiring returning citizens by signing the Fair Chance Business Pledge, demonstrating corporate social responsibility in action.

Case studies of success, therefore, are not just stories; they’re proof of the potential of returning citizens. They illustrate the transformative power of opportunity and support, reminding us of the importance of creating an inclusive, supportive environment for these individuals. After all, every returning citizen deserves a fair chance at success.

Partnerships for Progress

Cultivating hope through employment opportunities for returning citizens significantly relies on partnerships. These partnerships provide access to job skills, dignity, and hope, which are crucial for a positive reentry experience. Organizations like the Longford Trust offer paid internships allowing individuals with lived experience to work on criminal justice projects, using their unique perspectives to drive change.

Local collaborations between city leaders and organizations facilitate improved access to job training and educational programs for returning citizens, tailored to assist their transition. The WorkWell Partnership exemplifies a targeted, partner-based approach in its mission to ease the reentry of individuals transitioning from incarceration through personalized programs. Cities like Philadelphia and San Francisco have demonstrated that well-informed policies can help returning citizens find employment and improve societal outcomes.

Partnerships for progress, therefore, are pivotal in supporting the reintegration of returning citizens. By fostering collaborations and providing opportunities, these partnerships are not just supporting returning citizens; they’re also driving societal change. After all, progress is a collective effort, and every partnership brings us one step closer to a more inclusive, supportive society.

Valuing Voices: Inclusion in Policy and Decision-Making

A diverse and representative criminal justice system necessitates the inclusion of returning citizens in policy and decision-making processes. By integrating these individuals into institutional bodies within parliaments, they can voice their concerns and inform new laws. Returning citizens can become key influencers and decision-makers, significantly contributing to the success of organizations within the criminal justice sector.

Lived Experience Expert Groups, consisting of individuals with firsthand involvement in the criminal justice system, play a crucial role in increasing representation and leadership within the sector. However, it’s not just about representation; it’s also about creating an environment that supports and values these voices. Legislation and enforcement of anti-discrimination rules are strategies to combat employment discrimination against people with criminal records. Measures like automatic expungement of criminal records help decrease stigma and open up more employment opportunities for returning citizens.

Valuing voices, therefore, is about more than just inclusion; it’s about recognition, respect, and reform. By including the voices of returning citizens in policy and decision-making processes, we ensure a criminal justice system that is:

  • diverse
  • informed
  • effective
  • representative of the communities it serves.

Advisory Roles and Advocacy Groups

Advisory roles and advocacy groups led by returning citizens play a crucial role in increasing representation and leadership within the criminal justice sector. The Lived Experience Expert Group, for instance, advocates for greater representation and leadership of individuals with firsthand criminal justice system experience within the sector. Initiatives like ELEVATE CJS create defined routes for those with lived experience to ascend into senior decision-making positions, collaborating with government and industry stakeholders.

Partnerships with organizations such as the Longford Trust are providing paid internships, allowing individuals with lived experience to engage in substantial work like policy development and criminal justice media reporting. Advocacy is strengthened through the inclusion of people who have experienced the criminal justice system firsthand, with groups like the Criminal Justice Alliance emphasizing the importance of their perspectives in leadership and academic research.

Advisory roles and advocacy groups, therefore, are not just platforms for representation; they’re catalysts for change. By including returning citizens in these roles, we’re not just acknowledging their experiences; we’re also leveraging their insights to drive systemic change. After all, a system that values all voices is one that is truly inclusive and effective.

The Ripple Effect of Informed Policy

Policies shaped by lived experiences have the potential to generate a positive ripple effect throughout society. These policies have already shown successes, including programs that have led to reduced arrests and improved employment outcomes for returning citizens. A long-term goal of the U.S. criminal justice policy includes reducing the over-reliance on incarceration, signaling a shift towards shorter prison terms, community sanctions, and closing prisons.

Embedding returning citizens’ experiences into policy-making aligns with this strategic goal, helping to alleviate systemic issues within the criminal justice system. By infusing policy-making with the insights and experiences of those who have navigated the system firsthand, we ensure that our policies are:

  • Informed
  • Compassionate
  • Fair
  • Reflective of the realities of those they affect.

The ripple effect of informed policy, therefore, extends beyond its immediate impact. It shapes the narrative around reintegration, fosters a more inclusive society, and drives systemic change within the criminal justice system. By valuing the voices and experiences of returning citizens, we’re not just reforming our policies; we’re transforming our society.

Navigating New Norms: Social Integration Challenges and Solutions

A critical phase in the lives of incarcerated individuals is the reentry transition when they return to their communities. This transition is often fraught with unique needs that often go unaddressed before release, complicating their integration and potential contributions to policy discussions. It’s a transition that requires us to navigate new norms, to rethink our perceptions, and to address the challenges that returning citizens face.

From overcoming stigma related to mental illness to building new identities, this transition is about more than just reintegration; it’s about resilience, empowerment, and hope.

Overcoming Stigma and Building New Identities

Significant obstacles confront returning citizens as they reenter society. Among these is the stigma associated with a criminal record. This stigma often leads to being denied admission to college programs and job opportunities. It’s a barrier that extends beyond the confines of the criminal justice system, hindering the reintegration process and limiting opportunities for returning citizens.

Efforts are being made to combat this stigma. City leaders, for instance, are conducting awareness campaigns to educate the public on the benefits of giving returning citizens a second chance. Revised hiring practices, tax incentives for employers, and ‘ban the box’ initiatives are among the policy efforts in place to assist the reintegration of returning citizens into the workforce.

Overcoming stigma and building new identities, therefore, are crucial steps in the reintegration process. They’re about recognizing the value of every individual, regardless of their past. They’re about fostering an environment where returning citizens can successfully reintegrate, being seen, heard, and valued – not for their past mistakes, but for their potential and their contribution to society.

Holistic Approaches to Support

Rather than being limited to individual services, support for returning citizens should comprehensively address their unique needs. Organizations are implementing ‘One Stop Shop’ models that offer a comprehensive array of support services to assist formerly incarcerated individuals in rebuilding their lives upon reentry. These services address a range of deficits, including drug and alcohol addictions, mental and physical illnesses, and lack of work experience.

Workplace support systems, including mentorship, counseling, and flexible work arrangements, are essential to accommodate the unique reintegration needs of returning citizens. Inclusive services like housing, homeownership counseling, and small business growth are pivotal for the holistic rehabilitation of individuals. Integrating halfway houses, work-release programs, and family support can facilitate smoother reentry for returning citizens.

Holistic approaches to support, therefore, are about more than just providing services; they’re about understanding and addressing the unique needs of each returning citizen. They’re about fostering an environment where these individuals feel supported, empowered, and hopeful about their future. After all, a holistic approach to support is a holistic approach to reintegration – one that values the individual as a whole, not just their past.

The Power of Perspective: Leveraging Lived Experiences for Research and Development

In research and development, the power of perspective serves as a potent tool. By incorporating individuals with lived experiences in criminal justice research, we can deepen our understanding and enhance our research agendas in the context of real-world situations. These individuals, each a unique person, bring invaluable firsthand insights, contributing to innovative solutions and making interventions more effective as part of a research team.

Their perspectives ensure that our research outcomes align with the complexities of real-world scenarios.

Bridging Academia and Authenticity

Aligning our research outcomes with real-world complexities is ensured by the collaboration between academia and returning citizens. Philosophical approaches, like that of Husserl, which equally valued both objective and subjective experiences, underpin this collaboration. By engaging peer supporters with lived experiences of recovery and criminal justice involvement, we infuse real-world complexities into academic studies.

Bridging academia and authenticity, therefore, isn’t just about collaboration; it’s about recognizing the power of lived experiences in shaping our understanding. It’s about ensuring that our research, including studies conducted by national academies and published by the National Academies Press, is not just informed, but also authentic and reflective of the realities of those it aims to serve. By bridging academia and authenticity, we’re not just enriching our research; we’re also enriching our understanding.

Innovations Inspired by Experience

Lived experiences are driving innovations in the criminal justice sector. Initiatives like the Serious and Violent Offender Reentry Initiative (SVORI) and the Second Chance Act (SCA) are testament to this. These federal efforts support state and local agencies in addressing reentry challenges, inspired by the lived experiences of returning citizens.

Innovations inspired by experience, therefore, aren’t just about developing new programs or initiatives; they’re about recognizing the power of lived experiences in driving change. They’re about valuing the insights and perspectives of returning citizens and using them to inform, inspire, and innovate. By leveraging these experiences, we’re not just driving innovation; we’re also driving progress.

Embracing Diversity: Inclusivity in Community Justice Models

The aim of inclusive community justice models is to infuse diversity and foster inclusivity within the justice system. These models, like the Cognitive Community model employed in Virginia’s correctional facilities, promote inclusivity and foster a sense of community among returning citizens. Community Justice Centers serve as diversion preferences for individuals in crisis, addressing public safety and health goals through early intervention.

Existing jail and prison correctional systems are undergoing organizational changes to implement models that value diverse lived experiences.

Restorative Justice Initiatives

Restorative justice presents a framework of principles and practices to address conflict by enabling dialogue and repairing harm. Originating in indigenous societies, these initiatives focus on:

  • addressing harm
  • promoting healing
  • fostering dialogue and understanding
  • promoting a sense of community, respect, and understanding

Rather than punishing offenders, restorative justice initiatives aim to promote healing and restore relationships.

Restorative justice initiatives, therefore, are about more than just addressing conflict; they’re about promoting healing, understanding, and community. They’re about recognizing the value of dialogue and the power of understanding in resolving conflict. By embracing these initiatives, we’re not just addressing harm; we’re also fostering a more inclusive, understanding, and compassionate society.

Rehabilitative Programs with a Human Touch

Rehabilitative programs with a human touch prioritize the individual, offering the support, guidance, and resources necessary for societal reintegration. State prisons are transitioning from a focus on incapacitation to an emphasis on rehabilitation, reflecting a shift in the way we approach criminal justice. Evidence-based programming, including:

  • Immersive cognitive communities
  • Education
  • Personal development

is key in helping incarcerated individuals lead successful lives after release.

Specialized case management services are being offered to divert youth from the judicial system, focusing on pre-trial defendants and providing intensive supervision and support. Residential treatment programs use cognitive behavioral approaches, traditional 12-step, and relapse prevention strategies to help reduce recidivism among returning citizens. These programs not only provide individuals with the support they need to reintegrate into society but also equip them with the tools they need to lead fulfilling, productive lives.

Rehabilitative programs with a human touch, therefore, are about more than just rehabilitation; they’re about respect, understanding, and support. They’re about recognizing the unique needs of each individual and providing them with the resources they need to succeed. By embracing these programs, we’re not just supporting reintegration; we’re also fostering a more compassionate, understanding, and inclusive society.


Returning citizens bring a wealth of lived experiences that can inform policy, drive reform, and inspire hope. By valuing these experiences, we can shape a criminal justice system that is not just effective, but also compassionate, inclusive, and representative of the communities it serves. From harnessing personal narratives and fostering community engagement to leveraging these experiences for research and development, the potential of returning citizens is vast and largely untapped. By recognizing their potential and providing them with the support, resources, and opportunities they need, we can drive systemic change and foster a more inclusive society. After all, every voice matters, and every experience counts

Frequently Asked Questions

How can lived experiences shape criminal justice reform?

Lived experiences in the criminal justice system offer valuable insights that can positively influence and shape reforms, leading to better policies and higher rates of successful community reintegration. This understanding can bring about more beneficial outcomes for society.

What role does education play in the reintegration of returning citizens?

Education plays a crucial role in the reintegration of returning citizens by providing tailored initiatives that equip individuals with skills for sustainable employment, thereby reducing recidivism rates.

How can employment opportunities cultivate hope for returning citizens?

Employment opportunities for returning citizens offer more than just income - they provide a sense of purpose and dignity, helping them reintegrate successfully into society. Inclusive workplace practices and anti-bias laws further support their journey to secure stable employment.

How are returning citizens included in policy and decision-making processes?

Returning citizens can participate in policy and decision-making processes by joining institutional bodies in parliaments and holding key roles in organizations within the criminal justice sector, contributing to the success of these organizations and influencing systemic change.

Why is it important to have inclusive community justice models?

It is important to have inclusive community justice models because they integrate diversity, foster inclusivity, and create a more representative and effective criminal justice system. This can lead to a fairer and more trusted justice system.

Send Us a Message

An email will be sent to the team